Values to the end of the 2026 season. Values for players still at their club, and for picks marked *, will move. How this works
Essendon are ahead so far
Essendon
+1.5*PAV so far
got
- Andrew Phillips
- 2019 pick 61 (Melbourne) → Ned Cahill
- 2019 pick 72
Carlton
−1.5*PAV so far
got
- 2019 pick 70 → Jy Farrar
- 2019 pick 57 (Geelong)
- The tradeEssendon +12.92019
- DraftEssendon +16.02019draft
- SeasonEssendon +21.12020
- SeasonEssendon +16.62021
- SeasonEssendon +8.72022
- SeasonEssendon +13.92023
- SeasonEssendon +2.22024
- SeasonEssendon +0.22025
- SeasonEssendon +1.52026
- Essendon gave2019 pick 70, 2019 pick 57 (Geelong)
- Carlton gaveAndrew Phillips, 2019 pick 61 (Melbourne), 2019 pick 72
Values are PAV (Player Approximate Value) value lines at the end of 2026: what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him, plus what a stint still open is expected to add. A pick whose draft is to come is valued at its slot.
This trade now (2026)
- Essendon+1.5*
- Carlton−1.5*
10trades in the chain
8clubs involved
Biggest values
- Jye Caldwell105.2 · Essendon
- Brodie Kemp67.4 · Carlton
- Sam Flanders49.0 · Gold Coast
* Totals leave out values not in yet.
Swipe sideways to follow the timeline.
Timeline, oldest first.
- 2019. This trade. Essendon get Andrew Phillips and 2 more. Carlton get 2019 pick 70 and 1 more.
- 2019. ESS ⇄ BRI. Essendon get Tom Cutler and 1 more. Brisbane Lions get 2020 round 3 (Essendon) and 1 more.
- 2019. GC ⇄ CAR. Gold Coast get 2019 pick 11 and 1 more. Carlton get 2019 pick 17 and 1 more.
- 2019. ESS ⇄ WC. Essendon get 2020 round 4 (West Coast). West Coast get 2019 pick 58 (St Kilda).
- 2019. PA ⇄ CAR. Port Adelaide get 2019 pick 55 and 1 more. Carlton get 2019 pick 20 (GWS).
- 2019. BRI ⇄ PA. Picks moved on.
- 2019. Draft. Farrar (pick 60), Cahill (pick 56), Georgiades (pick 18) and 7 more.
- 2020. ESS ⇄ PA. Essendon get 2020 pick 29 and 1 more. Port Adelaide get Orazio Fantasia and 1 more.
- 2020. ESS ⇄ GWS. Essendon get Jye Caldwell and 2 more. GWS get 2020 pick 29 and 1 more.
- 2020. ESS ⇄ STK. Essendon get Nick Hind and 1 more. St Kilda get 2020 pick 67 (Essendon) and 1 more.
- 2020. ESS ⇄ BRI. Essendon get 2020 pick 50 and 1 more. Brisbane Lions get 2020 pick 42.
- 2020. Draft. Laurie (pick 22), Highmore (pick 45), Sharp (pick 43).
- 2021. Draft. Willis (pick 32), McDonagh (pick 50).
- 2026: Essendon +1.5*, Carlton −1.5*.
This trade over time
Each club’s net on this trade at the trade, at each draft and at the end of each season. Above the middle line, the club is ahead. A hollow point leaves out values not in yet.
End of 2026
- +1.5*Essendon
- −1.5*Carlton
Show the values
| When | Essendon | Carlton |
|---|---|---|
| At the trade, 2019 | +12.9 | −12.9 |
| 2019 draft | +16.0* | −16.0* |
| End of 2020 | +21.1* | −21.1* |
| End of 2021 | +16.6* | −16.6* |
| End of 2022 | +8.7* | −8.7* |
| End of 2023 | +13.9* | −13.9* |
| End of 2024 | +2.2* | −2.2* |
| End of 2025 | +0.2* | −0.2* |
| End of 2026 | +1.5* | −1.5* |
Trade details
What each club gave, what every asset became, and its value at the trade.
Essendon gave Carlton
- 2019 pick 70became Jy Farrar (at Gold Coast) · at the trade 18.427.1
- 2019 pick 57 (Geelong)not used · at the trade 22.10.0
Carlton received27.1
Carlton gave Essendon
- Andrew Phillipsfirst stint at Essendon · at the trade 14.626.5
- 2019 pick 61 (Melbourne)became Ned Cahill · at the trade 20.82.1
- 2019 pick 72used to match a bid not priced yet · at the trade 17.9not in yet
Essendon received28.6*
On this trade alone
- Essendon+1.5*at the trade +12.9
- Carlton−1.5*at the trade −12.9
With what each club did next
- Essendon+149.1+147.5 from 6 later tradesAll Essendon chains
- Carlton−28.3*−26.8 from 2 later tradesAll Carlton chains
Who they ended up with
Each player, after every later trade. A green dot means the player is still at the club.
What Essendon ended up with
EssendonJye Caldwell
From GWS in the 2020 trade.
105.2PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Essendon · value will move
EssendonNick Hind
From St Kilda in the 2020 trade.
42.3PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Essendon · value will move
EssendonAndrew Phillips
From Carlton in the 2019 trade.
26.5PAV produced
Left Essendon · value is final
EssendonTom Cutler
From Brisbane Lions in the 2019 trade.
15.0PAV produced
Left Essendon · value is final
EssendonNed Cahill
Taken with pick 56 in 2019, with 2019 pick 61 (Melbourne) from Carlton.
2.1PAV produced
Left Essendon · value is final
EssendonGarrett McDonagh
Taken with pick 50 in 2021, with 2021 round 3 (Port Adelaide) from Port Adelaide.
0.0PAV produced
Left Essendon · value is final
Essendon2020 pick 77 (Port Adelaide)
From St Kilda. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
Essendon2020 pick 50
From Brisbane Lions. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
Essendon2020 pick 49
From Brisbane Lions. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
What Carlton ended up with
CarltonBrodie Kemp
Taken with pick 17 in 2019, with 2019 pick 17 from Gold Coast.
67.4PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Carlton · value will move
CarltonSam Philp
Taken with pick 20 in 2019, with 2019 pick 20 (GWS) from Port Adelaide.
0.9PAV produced
Left Carlton · value is final
Carlton2019 pick 57 (Geelong)
From Essendon. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
Now at other clubs
Gold CoastSam Flanders
Taken with pick 11 in 2019 by Gold Coast, with 2019 pick 11.
49.0PAV produced
Left Gold Coast · value is final
Gold CoastJy Farrar
Taken with pick 60 in 2019 by Gold Coast, with 2019 pick 62.
27.1PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Gold Coast · value will move
Port Adelaide2019 pick 55
From Carlton. Port Adelaide used it to match a bid for Jackson Mead.
18.94PAV, share of Jackson Mead
Jackson Mead still at Port Adelaide · value will move
Brisbane LionsDeven Robertson
Taken with pick 22 in 2019 by Brisbane Lions, with 2019 pick 22.
12.9PAV produced
Left Brisbane Lions · value is final
Port AdelaideOrazio Fantasia
From Essendon in the 2020 trade.
10.3PAV produced
Left Port Adelaide · value is final
Western Bulldogs2020 pick 29
From GWS. Western Bulldogs used it to match a bid for Jamarra Ugle-Hagan.
8.71PAV, share of Jamarra Ugle-Hagan
Jamarra Ugle-Hagan left Western Bulldogs · value is final
St KildaTom Highmore
Taken with pick 45 in 2020 by St Kilda, with 2020 pick 43 (Essendon).
4.6PAV produced
Left St Kilda · value is final
Brisbane LionsHarry Sharp
Taken with pick 43 in 2020 by Brisbane Lions, with 2020 pick 42.
4.0PAV produced
Left Brisbane Lions · value is final
Port Adelaide2020 pick 73 (West Coast)
From Essendon. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
GeelongJames Willis
Taken with pick 32 in 2021 by Geelong, with 2021 round 2 (Essendon).
0.0PAV produced
Left Geelong · value is final
St Kilda2020 pick 67 (Essendon)
From Essendon. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
St Kilda2020 pick 74 (Collingwood)
From Essendon. Not used at the draft.
0.0PAV produced
West CoastBen Johnson
Taken with pick 58 in 2019 by West Coast, with 2019 pick 58 (St Kilda).
0.0PAV produced
Left West Coast · value is final
Port Adelaide2019 pick 72
From Brisbane Lions. Used to match a bid not priced yet.
—value not in yet
Lineage
Every asset from the trade, followed to the player it became. Open any trade button to see that trade here.
- held by the club
- after it left the club
- bar length is PAV
Essendon received
Andrew Phillips
Andrew Phillips · 26.52019 pick 61 (Melbourne)
via 2019via 2019Ned Cahill (pick 56, 2019) · 2.12019 pick 72
BID MATCHValue pending
Carlton received
2019 pick 70
Jy Farrar (pick 60, 2019) at Gold Coast · 27.12019 pick 57 (Geelong)
via 2019Not used · 0.0