Skip to content
Statly
HomeTradesDraft record

Values to the end of the 2026 season. Values for players still at their club, and for picks marked *, will move. How this works

AFL trades / 2023 / Essendon ⇄ Western Bulldogs ⇄ Carlton ⇄ St Kilda
AFL trades · 2023Essendon ⇄ Western Bulldogs ⇄ Carlton ⇄ St Kilda

Western Bulldogs are ahead so far

  • Essendon

    −3.3

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2023 pick 35 (St Kilda) → Luamon Lual
    • 2024 round 4 (Carlton) → Cody Anderson
  • Western Bulldogs

    +13.1

    PAV so far

    got

    • Nick Coffield
    • 2023 pick 56 (St Kilda) → Lachlan Smith
    • 2023 pick 52 (Essendon) → Jordan Croft
  • Carlton

    −10.3

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2024 round 3 (Essendon) → Tom Gross
    • 2024 round 4 (Western Bulldogs)
    • 2024 round 4 (Fremantle)
  • St Kilda

    +0.5

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) → Ethan Read
    • 2024 round 3 (Carlton) → Lucca Grego
    • Paddy Dow
  1. The tradeWestern Bulldogs +22.92023
  2. DraftWestern Bulldogs +11.32023draft
  3. SeasonEssendon +6.62024
  4. DraftSt Kilda +25.02024draft
  5. SeasonWestern Bulldogs +9.72025
  6. SeasonWestern Bulldogs +13.12026
  • ESSEssendon gave2024 round 3 (Essendon), 2023 pick 52 (Essendon)
  • WBDWestern Bulldogs gave2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions), 2024 round 4 (Western Bulldogs)
  • CARCarlton gave2024 round 3 (Carlton), 2024 round 4 (Carlton), Paddy Dow
  • STKSt Kilda gave2023 pick 35 (St Kilda), Nick Coffield, 2023 pick 56 (St Kilda), 2024 round 4 (Fremantle)

Values are PAV (Player Approximate Value) value lines at the end of 2026: what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him, plus what a stint still open is expected to add. A pick whose draft is to come is valued at its slot.

This trade now (2026)

  • ESSEssendon−3.3
  • WBDWestern Bulldogs+13.1
  • CARCarlton−10.3
  • STKSt Kilda+0.5

14trades in the chain

12clubs involved

Biggest values

  • MRMurphy Reid130.3 · Fremantle
  • JSJagga Smith123.7 · Carlton
  • JBJoe Berry89.9 · Port Adelaide

Swipe sideways to follow the timeline.

REID130.3 · FremantleSMITH123.7 · CarltonBERRY89.9 · Port Adelaide2026ESS −3.3WBD +13.1CAR −10.3STK +0.52023This tradeEssendon get 2023 pick35 (St Kilda) and 1more. Western Bulldogsget Nick Coffield and 2…2023ESS ⇄ PAEssendon get XavierDuursma. Port Adelaideget BrandonZerk-Thatcher and 3…2023GWS ⇄ STKGWS get 2024 round 3(Carlton). St Kilda get2023 pick 50.2023GC ⇄ STKGold Coast get 2023pick 40 (BrisbaneLions) and 1 more. StKilda get 2023 pick 27…2023GC ⇄ CARGold Coast get 2023pick 26 and 1 more.Carlton get ElijahHollands and 2 more.2023PA ⇄ HAWPicks moved on.2023DraftLual (pick 39), Smith(pick 47), Garcia (pick50) and 4 more.2024BRI ⇄ CARBrisbane Lions get 2024pick 34 (Carlton) and 1more. Carlton get 2025round 2 (Brisbane…2024WC ⇄ RIC ⇄ CARWest Coast get 2024pick 12 (Carlton) and 3more. Richmond get 2024pick 14 (Hawthorn)…2024ESS ⇄ GWSEssendon get 2024 pick53 (Carlton). GWS getJake Stringer.2024ESS ⇄ BRIEssendon get 2024 pick37 (GWS) and 2 more.Brisbane Lions get 2024pick 40 (Sydney) and 4…2024Other dealsPicks moved on: WC ⇄BRI, GC ⇄ PA ⇄ COL, WC⇄ PA.2024DraftGross (pick 46), Grego(pick 48), Anderson(pick 64) and 13 more.2025WC ⇄ CARWest Coast get 2025pick 41 (BrisbaneLions). Carlton getCampbell Chesser.2025DraftTaylor (pick 11),Dalton (pick 34).

Timeline, oldest first.

  1. 2023. This trade. Essendon get 2023 pick 35 (St Kilda) and 1 more. Western Bulldogs get Nick Coffield and 2 more. Carlton get 2024 round 3 (Essendon) and 2 more. St Kilda get 2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) and 2 more.
  2. 2023. ESS ⇄ PA. Essendon get Xavier Duursma. Port Adelaide get Brandon Zerk-Thatcher and 3 more.
  3. 2023. GWS ⇄ STK. GWS get 2024 round 3 (Carlton). St Kilda get 2023 pick 50.
  4. 2023. GC ⇄ STK. Gold Coast get 2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) and 1 more. St Kilda get 2023 pick 27 (Gold Coast).
  5. 2023. GC ⇄ CAR. Gold Coast get 2023 pick 26 and 1 more. Carlton get Elijah Hollands and 2 more.
  6. 2023. PA ⇄ HAW. Picks moved on.
  7. 2023. Draft. Lual (pick 39), Smith (pick 47), Garcia (pick 50) and 4 more.
  8. 2024. BRI ⇄ CAR. Brisbane Lions get 2024 pick 34 (Carlton) and 1 more. Carlton get 2025 round 2 (Brisbane Lions) and 1 more.
  9. 2024. WC ⇄ RIC ⇄ CAR. West Coast get 2024 pick 12 (Carlton) and 3 more. Richmond get 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn). Carlton get 2024 pick 3 (West Coast) and 2 more.
  10. 2024. ESS ⇄ GWS. Essendon get 2024 pick 53 (Carlton). GWS get Jake Stringer.
  11. 2024. ESS ⇄ BRI. Essendon get 2024 pick 37 (GWS) and 2 more. Brisbane Lions get 2024 pick 40 (Sydney) and 4 more.
  12. 2024. Other deals. Picks moved on: WC ⇄ BRI, GC ⇄ PA ⇄ COL, WC ⇄ PA.
  13. 2024. Draft. Gross (pick 46), Grego (pick 48), Anderson (pick 64) and 13 more.
  14. 2025. WC ⇄ CAR. West Coast get 2025 pick 41 (Brisbane Lions). Carlton get Campbell Chesser.
  15. 2025. Draft. Taylor (pick 11), Dalton (pick 34).
  16. 2026: Essendon −3.3, Western Bulldogs +13.1, Carlton −10.3, St Kilda +0.5.

This trade over time

Each club’s net on this trade at the trade, at each draft and at the end of each season. Above the middle line, the club is ahead.

End of 2026

  • ESS−3.3Essendon
  • WBD+13.1Western Bulldogs
  • CAR−10.3Carlton
  • STK+0.5St Kilda
+60+300−30−60TradeDraft2024Draft20252026WBD +13.1STK +0.5CAR −10.3
Show the values
Each club’s net on this trade at each point in time
WhenESSEssendonWBDWestern BulldogsCARCarltonSTKSt Kilda
At the trade, 2023+3.7+22.9−15.9−10.7
2023 draft+9.6+11.3−15.9−5.0
End of 2024+6.6+3.9−14.7+4.2
2024 draft+6.2+22.0−53.3+25.0
End of 2025+2.8+9.7−19.4+6.8
End of 2026−3.3+13.1−10.3+0.5

Trade details

What each club gave, what every asset became, and its value at the trade.

ESSEssendon gave

  • 2024 round 3 (Essendon) to Carltonbecame Tom Gross (at West Coast) · at the trade 24.926.4
  • 2023 pick 52 (Essendon) to Western Bulldogsused to match a bid · share of Jordan Croft · at the trade 24.110.39

Total given36.8

WBDWestern Bulldogs gave

  • 2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) to St Kildaused to match a bid · share of Ethan Read · at the trade 30.531.60
  • 2024 round 4 (Western Bulldogs) to Carltonnot used · at the trade 18.10.0

Total given31.6

CARCarlton gave

  • 2024 round 3 (Carlton) to St Kildabecame Lucca Grego (at West Coast) · at the trade 23.717.3
  • 2024 round 4 (Carlton) to Essendonbecame Cody Anderson (at Hawthorn) · at the trade 18.412.4
  • Paddy Dow to St Kildafirst stint at St Kilda · at the trade 35.56.9

Total given36.6

STKSt Kilda gave

  • 2023 pick 35 (St Kilda) to Essendonbecame Luamon Lual · at the trade 34.421.0
  • Nick Coffield to Western Bulldogsfirst stint at Western Bulldogs · at the trade 24.919.6
  • 2023 pick 56 (St Kilda) to Western Bulldogsbecame Lachlan Smith · at the trade 22.514.7
  • 2024 round 4 (Fremantle) to Carltonnot used · at the trade 18.60.0

Total given55.3

On this trade alone

  • ESSEssendon−3.3at the trade +3.7
  • WBDWestern Bulldogs+13.1at the trade +22.9
  • CARCarlton−10.3at the trade −15.9
  • STKSt Kilda+0.5at the trade −10.7

With what each club did next

  • ESSEssendon−7.8−4.5 from 1 later tradeAll Essendon chains
  • WBDWestern Bulldogs+13.1no later tradeAll Western Bulldogs chains
  • CARCarlton−116.6−106.3 from 4 later tradesAll Carlton chains
  • STKSt Kilda+41.0+40.6 from 2 later tradesAll St Kilda chains

Picks used to match a bid

A pick spent on a bid is swapped for a share of the player, by the points it covered.

BID MATCH

2023 pick 52 (Essendon) became a share of Jordan Croft

Western Bulldogs matched a bid for Jordan Croft at pick 15 in 2023. The price was 889.6 points, paid with 3 picks.

10.392023 pick 52 (Essendon)’s share: 22.1% of Jordan Croft’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Jordan Croft
PickPoints coveredShare
R3 (GCS) - Pick 4836240.7%
R3 (RCH) - Pick 5033137.2%
R3 (ESS) - Pick 52 (this pick) · part used196.622.1%

R3 (ESS) - Pick 52 had 119.4 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (119.4 points) and Leftover-points pick (119.4 points).

BID MATCH

2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) became a share of Ethan Read

Gold Coast matched a bid for Ethan Read at pick 9 in 2023. The price was 1,175.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

31.602023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions)’s share: 39.6% of Ethan Read’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Ethan Read
PickPoints coveredShare
R2 (MEL) - Pick 3654246.1%
R2 (BRL) - Pick 40 (this pick)46539.6%
R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 · part used168.214.3%

R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 had 260.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (260.8 points) and Leftover-points pick (260.8 points).

BID MATCH

2024 pick 63 (West Coast) became a share of Ben Camporeale

Carlton matched a bid for Ben Camporeale at pick 43 in 2024. The price was 181 points, paid with 1 picks.

17.652024 pick 63 (West Coast)’s share: 100.0% of Ben Camporeale’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Ben Camporeale
PickPoints coveredShare
R4 (WCE) - Pick 63 (this pick) · part used181100.0%

R4 (WCE) - Pick 63 had 13 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (13 points).

BID MATCH

2023 pick 42 became a share of Ethan Read

Gold Coast matched a bid for Ethan Read at pick 9 in 2023. The price was 1,175.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

11.432023 pick 42’s share: 14.3% of Ethan Read’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Ethan Read
PickPoints coveredShare
R2 (MEL) - Pick 3654246.1%
R2 (BRL) - Pick 4046539.6%
R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 (this pick) · part used168.214.3%

R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 had 260.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (260.8 points) and Leftover-points pick (260.8 points).

Who they ended up with

Each player, after every later trade. A green dot means the player is still at the club.

ESSWhat Essendon ended up with

  • ESSEssendonXavier Duursma

    From Port Adelaide in the 2023 trade.

    52.1PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Essendon · value will move

  • ESSEssendonLuamon Lual

    Taken with pick 39 in 2023, with 2023 pick 35 (St Kilda) from St Kilda.

    21.0PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Essendon · value will move

WBDWhat Western Bulldogs ended up with

  • WBDWestern BulldogsNick Coffield

    From St Kilda in the 2023 trade.

    19.6PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Western Bulldogs · value will move

  • WBDWestern BulldogsLachlan Smith

    Taken with pick 47 in 2023, with 2023 pick 56 (St Kilda) from St Kilda.

    14.7PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Western Bulldogs · value will move

  • WBDWestern Bulldogs2023 pick 52 (Essendon)

    From Essendon. Western Bulldogs used it to match a bid for Jordan Croft.

    10.39PAV, share of Jordan Croft

    Jordan Croft still at Western Bulldogs · value will move

CARWhat Carlton ended up with

  • CARCarltonJagga Smith

    Taken with pick 3 in 2024, with 2024 pick 3 (West Coast) from West Coast.

    123.7PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarltonElijah Hollands

    From Gold Coast in the 2023 trade.

    42.1PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarltonBilly Wilson

    Taken with pick 34 in 2023, with 2023 pick 28 (Fremantle) from Gold Coast.

    36.0PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2024 pick 63 (West Coast)

    From West Coast. Carlton used it to match a bid for Ben Camporeale.

    17.65PAV, share of Ben Camporeale

    Ben Camporeale still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarltonCampbell Chesser

    From West Coast in the 2025 trade.

    13.2PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2024 round 4 (Western Bulldogs)

    From Western Bulldogs. Not used at the draft.

    0.0PAV produced

  • CARCarlton2024 round 4 (Fremantle)

    From St Kilda. Not used at the draft.

    0.0PAV produced

  • CARCarlton2024 pick 68

    From West Coast. Not used at the draft.

    0.0PAV produced

STKWhat St Kilda ended up with

  • STKSt KildaHugo Garcia

    Taken with pick 50 in 2023, with 2023 pick 50 from GWS.

    71.8PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at St Kilda · value will move

  • STKSt KildaAngus Hastie

    Taken with pick 33 in 2023, with 2023 pick 27 (Gold Coast) from Gold Coast.

    29.1PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at St Kilda · value will move

  • STKSt KildaPaddy Dow

    From Carlton in the 2023 trade.

    6.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at St Kilda · value will move

Now at other clubs

  • FREFremantleMurphy Reid

    Taken with pick 17 in 2024 by Fremantle, with 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn).

    130.3PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Fremantle · value will move

  • PAPort AdelaideJoe Berry

    Taken with pick 15 in 2024 by Port Adelaide, with 2024 pick 15 (Carlton).

    89.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Port Adelaide · value will move

  • GCGold Coast2023 pick 26

    From Carlton. Gold Coast used it to match a bid for Jed Walter.

    46.96PAV, share of Jed Walter

    Jed Walter still at Gold Coast · value will move

  • HAWHawthornJack Dalton

    Taken with pick 34 in 2025 by Hawthorn, with 2025 pick 34 (Brisbane Lions).

    35.7PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Hawthorn · value will move

  • WCWest CoastHamish Davis

    Taken with pick 65 in 2024 by West Coast, with 2024 pick 73 (Hawthorn).

    34.0PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

  • GCGold Coast2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions)

    From St Kilda. Gold Coast used it to match a bid for Ethan Read.

    31.60PAV, share of Ethan Read

    Ethan Read still at Gold Coast · value will move

  • WCWest CoastTom Gross

    Taken with pick 46 in 2024 by West Coast, with 2024 pick 45 (Essendon).

    26.4PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

  • PAPort AdelaideBrandon Zerk-Thatcher

    From Essendon in the 2023 trade.

    25.5PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Port Adelaide · value will move

  • GWSGWSJack Ough

    Taken with pick 36 in 2024 by GWS, with 2024 pick 34 (Carlton).

    25.4PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at GWS · value will move

  • WCWest CoastMatthew Owies

    From Carlton in the 2024 trade.

    20.2PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

  • PAPort AdelaideWill Lorenz

    Taken with pick 57 in 2023 by Port Adelaide, with 2023 pick 73 (Sydney).

    18.7PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Port Adelaide · value will move

  • WCWest CoastLucca Grego

    Taken with pick 48 in 2024 by West Coast, with 2024 pick 46 (Carlton).

    17.3PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

  • WBDWestern BulldogsLuke Kennedy

    Taken with pick 62 in 2024 by Western Bulldogs, with 2024 pick 62 (Gold Coast).

    16.8PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Western Bulldogs · value will move

  • HAWHawthornCody Anderson

    Taken with pick 64 in 2024 by Hawthorn, with 2024 round 4 (Carlton).

    12.4PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Hawthorn · value will move

  • GCGold Coast2023 pick 42

    From St Kilda. Gold Coast used it to match a bid for Ethan Read.

    11.43PAV, share of Ethan Read

    Ethan Read still at Gold Coast · value will move

  • NMNorth Melbourne2024 round 4 (Essendon)

    From Port Adelaide. Not used at the draft.

    0.0PAV produced

Lineage

Every asset from the trade, followed to the player it became. Open any ⇄trade button to see that trade here.

  • held by the club
  • after it left the club
  • bar length is PAV

ESSEssendon received

  • 2023 pick 35 (St Kilda)

    Luamon Lual (pick 39, 2023) · 21.0
  • 2024 round 4 (Carlton)

    Cody Anderson (pick 64, 2024) at Hawthorn · 12.4

WBDWestern Bulldogs received

  • Nick Coffield

    Nick Coffield · 19.6
  • 2023 pick 56 (St Kilda)

    Lachlan Smith (pick 47, 2023) · 14.7
  • 2023 pick 52 (Essendon)

    BID MATCHShare of Jordan Croft: 10.39

CARCarlton received

  • 2024 round 3 (Essendon)

    Tom Gross (pick 46, 2024) at West Coast · 26.4
  • 2024 round 4 (Western Bulldogs)

    Not used · 0.0
  • 2024 round 4 (Fremantle)

    via 2023Not used · 0.0

STKSt Kilda received

  • 2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions)

    via 2022BID MATCHShare of Ethan Read: 31.60
  • 2024 round 3 (Carlton)

    Lucca Grego (pick 48, 2024) at West Coast · 17.3
  • Paddy Dow

    Paddy Dow · 6.9

Trades in this lineage

PAV (Player Approximate Value): what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him to 2026, plus what an open stint is expected to add. A pick used to match a bid is worth its share of the player.

Players still at their club: values will move. Club colours only, no club marks.

  • How trades are valued
  • Outcomes methodology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Data deletion

© 2026 Statly