Skip to content
Statly
HomeTradesDraft record

Values to the end of the 2026 season. Values for players still at their club, and for picks marked *, will move. How this works

AFL trades / 2024 / Hawthorn ⇄ Carlton
AFL trades · 2024Hawthorn ⇄ Carlton

Hawthorn are ahead so far

  • Hawthorn

    +14.3

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2025 round 1 (Carlton) → Dyson Sharp
    • 2025 round 2 (Carlton) → Harry Kyle
  • Carlton

    −14.3

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn) → Murphy Reid
  1. The tradeHawthorn +60.02024
  2. DraftHawthorn +69.72024draft
  3. SeasonHawthorn +17.12025
  4. DraftHawthorn +4.72025draft
  5. SeasonHawthorn +14.32026
  • HAWHawthorn gave2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn)
  • CARCarlton gave2025 round 1 (Carlton), 2025 round 2 (Carlton)

Values are PAV (Player Approximate Value) value lines at the end of 2026: what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him, plus what a stint still open is expected to add. A pick whose draft is to come is valued at its slot.

This trade now (2026)

  • HAWHawthorn+14.3
  • CARCarlton−14.3

12trades in the chain

11clubs involved

Biggest values

  • MRMurphy Reid130.3 · Fremantle
  • JSJagga Smith123.7 · Carlton
  • DSDyson Sharp99.3 · Essendon

Swipe sideways to follow the timeline.

REID130.3 · FremantleSMITH123.7 · CarltonSHARP99.3 · Essendon2026HAW +14.3CAR −14.32024This tradeHawthorn get 2025 round1 (Carlton) and 1 more.Carlton get 2024 pick14 (Hawthorn).2024WC ⇄ RIC ⇄ CARWest Coast get 2024pick 12 (Carlton) and 3more. Richmond get 2024pick 14 (Hawthorn)…2024RIC ⇄ FREPicks moved on.2024DraftReid (pick 17), Smith(pick 3), Berry (pick15) and 4 more.2025HAW ⇄ CARHawthorn get 2025 pick10 and 1 more. Carltonget 2025 pick 9(Carlton) and 3 more.2025ESS ⇄ CAREssendon get 2025 pick9 (Carlton) and 1 more.Carlton get 2025 pick21 and 2 more.2025CAR ⇄ SYDCarlton get 2025 pick11 (Sydney) and 3 more.Sydney get 2025 pick 31(Carlton) and 3 more.2025BRI ⇄ HAWBrisbane Lions get 2025pick 22 and 1 more.Hawthorn get 2025 pick17 (Hawthorn).2025GWS ⇄ HAWGWS get 2025 pick 14.Hawthorn get 2025 pick16 (Western Bulldogs)and 1 more.2025GC ⇄ CARGold Coast get 2025pick 28 (St Kilda).Carlton get 2026 round2 (Gold Coast).2025CAR ⇄ NMCarlton get 2025 pick25 (Richmond) and 2more. North Melbourneget 2025 pick 11…2025WC ⇄ HAWWest Coast get 2025pick 17 (WesternBulldogs). Hawthorn get2025 pick 18 and 1…2025BRI ⇄ CARBrisbane Lions get 2025pick 38 (NorthMelbourne). Carlton get2026 round 3 (Brisbane…2025DraftSharp (pick 13),Lindsay (pick 19),Dovaston (pick 16) and9 more.

Timeline, oldest first.

  1. 2024. This trade. Hawthorn get 2025 round 1 (Carlton) and 1 more. Carlton get 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn).
  2. 2024. WC ⇄ RIC ⇄ CAR. West Coast get 2024 pick 12 (Carlton) and 3 more. Richmond get 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn). Carlton get 2024 pick 3 (West Coast) and 2 more.
  3. 2024. RIC ⇄ FRE. Picks moved on.
  4. 2024. Draft. Reid (pick 17), Smith (pick 3), Berry (pick 15) and 4 more.
  5. 2025. HAW ⇄ CAR. Hawthorn get 2025 pick 10 and 1 more. Carlton get 2025 pick 9 (Carlton) and 3 more.
  6. 2025. ESS ⇄ CAR. Essendon get 2025 pick 9 (Carlton) and 1 more. Carlton get 2025 pick 21 and 2 more.
  7. 2025. CAR ⇄ SYD. Carlton get 2025 pick 11 (Sydney) and 3 more. Sydney get 2025 pick 31 (Carlton) and 3 more.
  8. 2025. BRI ⇄ HAW. Brisbane Lions get 2025 pick 22 and 1 more. Hawthorn get 2025 pick 17 (Hawthorn).
  9. 2025. GWS ⇄ HAW. GWS get 2025 pick 14. Hawthorn get 2025 pick 16 (Western Bulldogs) and 1 more.
  10. 2025. GC ⇄ CAR. Gold Coast get 2025 pick 28 (St Kilda). Carlton get 2026 round 2 (Gold Coast).
  11. 2025. CAR ⇄ NM. Carlton get 2025 pick 25 (Richmond) and 2 more. North Melbourne get 2025 pick 11 (Sydney) and 1 more.
  12. 2025. WC ⇄ HAW. West Coast get 2025 pick 17 (Western Bulldogs). Hawthorn get 2025 pick 18 and 1 more.
  13. 2025. BRI ⇄ CAR. Brisbane Lions get 2025 pick 38 (North Melbourne). Carlton get 2026 round 3 (Brisbane Lions).
  14. 2025. Draft. Sharp (pick 13), Lindsay (pick 19), Dovaston (pick 16) and 9 more.
  15. 2026: Hawthorn +14.3, Carlton −14.3.

This trade over time

Each club’s net on this trade at the trade, at each draft and at the end of each season. Above the middle line, the club is ahead.

End of 2026

  • HAW+14.3Hawthorn
  • CAR−14.3Carlton
+80+400−40−80TradeDraft2025Draft2026HAW +14.3CAR −14.3
Show the values
Each club’s net on this trade at each point in time
WhenHAWHawthornCARCarlton
At the trade, 2024+60.0−60.0
2024 draft+69.7−69.7
End of 2025+17.1−17.1
2025 draft+4.7−4.7
End of 2026+14.3−14.3

Trade details

What each club gave, what every asset became, and its value at the trade.

HAWHawthorn gave Carlton

  • 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn)became Murphy Reid (at Fremantle) · at the trade 71.7130.3

Carlton received130.3

CARCarlton gave Hawthorn

  • 2025 round 1 (Carlton)became Dyson Sharp (at Essendon) · at the trade 93.399.3
  • 2025 round 2 (Carlton)used to match a bid · share of Harry Kyle · at the trade 38.345.26

Hawthorn received144.6

On this trade alone

  • HAWHawthorn+14.3at the trade +60.0
  • CARCarlton−14.3at the trade −60.0

With what each club did next

  • HAWHawthorn−50.4−64.7 from 4 later tradesAll Hawthorn chains
  • CARCarlton+63.6+77.9 from 7 later tradesAll Carlton chains

Picks used to match a bid

A pick spent on a bid is swapped for a share of the player, by the points it covered.

BID MATCH

2025 round 2 (Carlton) became a share of Harry Kyle

Sydney matched a bid for Harry Kyle at pick 14 in 2025. The price was 921.6 points, paid with 2 picks.

45.262025 round 2 (Carlton)’s share: 60.9% of Harry Kyle’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Harry Kyle
PickPoints coveredShare
R2 (CAR) - Pick 31 (this pick)56160.9%
R2 (SYD) - Pick 32 · part used360.639.1%

R2 (SYD) - Pick 32 had 172.4 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (172.4 points).

BID MATCH

2025 pick 21 became a share of Harry Dean

Carlton matched a bid for Harry Dean at pick 3 in 2025. The price was 1,960.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

54.822025 pick 21’s share: 38.6% of Harry Dean’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Harry Dean
PickPoints coveredShare
R1 (ESS) - Pick 21 (this pick)75738.6%
R2 (RCH) - Pick 2565333.3%
R2 (ESS) - Pick 27 · part used550.228.1%

R2 (ESS) - Pick 27 had 39.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (39.8 points).

BID MATCH

2025 pick 25 (Richmond) became a share of Harry Dean

Carlton matched a bid for Harry Dean at pick 3 in 2025. The price was 1,960.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

47.292025 pick 25 (Richmond)’s share: 33.3% of Harry Dean’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Harry Dean
PickPoints coveredShare
R1 (ESS) - Pick 2175738.6%
R2 (RCH) - Pick 25 (this pick)65333.3%
R2 (ESS) - Pick 27 · part used550.228.1%

R2 (ESS) - Pick 27 had 39.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (39.8 points).

BID MATCH

2025 pick 27 (Essendon) became a share of Harry Dean

Carlton matched a bid for Harry Dean at pick 3 in 2025. The price was 1,960.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

39.842025 pick 27 (Essendon)’s share: 28.1% of Harry Dean’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Harry Dean
PickPoints coveredShare
R1 (ESS) - Pick 2175738.6%
R2 (RCH) - Pick 2565333.3%
R2 (ESS) - Pick 27 (this pick) · part used550.228.1%

R2 (ESS) - Pick 27 had 39.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (39.8 points).

BID MATCH

2024 pick 63 (West Coast) became a share of Ben Camporeale

Carlton matched a bid for Ben Camporeale at pick 43 in 2024. The price was 181 points, paid with 1 picks.

17.652024 pick 63 (West Coast)’s share: 100.0% of Ben Camporeale’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Ben Camporeale
PickPoints coveredShare
R4 (WCE) - Pick 63 (this pick) · part used181100.0%

R4 (WCE) - Pick 63 had 13 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (13 points).

BID MATCH

2025 pick 22 became a share of Daniel Annable

Brisbane Lions matched a bid for Daniel Annable at pick 6 in 2025. The price was 1,493.1 points, paid with 3 picks.

35.612025 pick 22’s share: 45.9% of Daniel Annable’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Daniel Annable
PickPoints coveredShare
R1 (CAR) - Pick 22 (this pick)68645.9%
R1 (WCE) - Pick 2365343.7%
R3 (WCE) - Pick 44 · part used154.110.3%

R3 (WCE) - Pick 44 had 102.9 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (102.9 points).

Who they ended up with

Each player, after every later trade. A green dot means the player is still at the club.

HAWWhat Hawthorn ended up with

  • HAWHawthornCameron Nairn

    Taken with pick 20 in 2025, with 2025 pick 18 from West Coast.

    45.8PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Hawthorn · value will move

  • HAWHawthorn2026 round 2 (GWS)

    From GWS. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 27.

    42.9PAV at its slot

  • HAWHawthorn2026 round 2 (St Kilda)

    From West Coast. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 29.

    40.5PAV at its slot

  • HAWHawthornAidan Schubert

    Taken with pick 23 in 2025, with 2025 pick 17 (Hawthorn) from Brisbane Lions.

    39.1PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Hawthorn · value will move

CARWhat Carlton ended up with

  • CARCarltonJagga Smith

    Taken with pick 3 in 2024, with 2024 pick 3 (West Coast) from West Coast.

    123.7PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2026 round 1 (Sydney)

    From Sydney. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 18.

    59.2PAV at its slot

  • CARCarlton2027 round 1 (Sydney)

    From Sydney. The 2027 draft is to come: valued at pick 18.

    59.2PAV at its slot

  • CARCarlton2025 pick 21

    From Essendon. Carlton used it to match a bid for Harry Dean.

    54.82PAV, share of Harry Dean

    Harry Dean still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2025 pick 25 (Richmond)

    From North Melbourne. Carlton used it to match a bid for Harry Dean.

    47.29PAV, share of Harry Dean

    Harry Dean still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2026 round 2 (North Melbourne)

    From North Melbourne. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 25.

    45.7PAV at its slot

  • CARCarlton2026 round 2 (Gold Coast)

    From Gold Coast. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 26.

    44.3PAV at its slot

  • CARCarlton2025 pick 27 (Essendon)

    From Essendon. Carlton used it to match a bid for Harry Dean.

    39.84PAV, share of Harry Dean

    Harry Dean still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarltonWill Hayward

    From Sydney in the 2025 trade.

    26.4PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2026 round 3 (Brisbane Lions)

    From Brisbane Lions. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 61.

    20.8PAV at its slot

  • CARCarlton2024 pick 63 (West Coast)

    From West Coast. Carlton used it to match a bid for Ben Camporeale.

    17.65PAV, share of Ben Camporeale

    Ben Camporeale still at Carlton · value will move

  • CARCarlton2024 pick 68

    From West Coast. Not used at the draft.

    0.0PAV produced

Now at other clubs

  • FREFremantleMurphy Reid

    Taken with pick 17 in 2024 by Fremantle, with 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn).

    130.3PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Fremantle · value will move

  • ESSEssendonDyson Sharp

    Taken with pick 13 in 2025 by Essendon, with 2025 pick 9 (Carlton).

    99.3PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Essendon · value will move

  • PAPort AdelaideJoe Berry

    Taken with pick 15 in 2024 by Port Adelaide, with 2024 pick 15 (Carlton).

    89.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Port Adelaide · value will move

  • WCWest CoastJosh Lindsay

    Taken with pick 19 in 2025 by West Coast, with 2025 pick 17 (Western Bulldogs).

    74.4PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

  • NMNorth MelbourneLachy Dovaston

    Taken with pick 16 in 2025 by North Melbourne, with 2025 pick 11 (Sydney).

    59.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at North Melbourne · value will move

  • GWSGWSOskar Taylor

    Taken with pick 15 in 2025 by GWS, with 2025 pick 14.

    50.7PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at GWS · value will move

  • SYDSydney2025 pick 31 (Carlton)

    From Carlton. Sydney used it to match a bid for Harry Kyle.

    45.26PAV, share of Harry Kyle

    Harry Kyle still at Sydney · value will move

  • SYDSydneyCharlie Curnow

    From Carlton in the 2025 trade.

    42.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Sydney · value will move

  • ESSEssendonMax Kondogiannis

    Taken with pick 36 in 2025 by Essendon, with 2025 pick 43.

    40.0PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Essendon · value will move

  • SYDSydney2027 round 2 (Carlton)

    From Carlton. The 2027 draft is to come: valued at pick 32.

    37.2PAV at its slot

  • BRIBrisbane Lions2025 pick 22

    From Hawthorn. Brisbane Lions used it to match a bid for Daniel Annable.

    35.61PAV, share of Daniel Annable

    Daniel Annable still at Brisbane Lions · value will move

  • WCWest CoastHamish Davis

    Taken with pick 65 in 2024 by West Coast, with 2024 pick 73 (Hawthorn).

    34.0PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

  • GCGold CoastAvery Thomas

    Taken with pick 28 in 2025 by Gold Coast, with 2025 pick 28 (St Kilda).

    32.2PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Gold Coast · value will move

  • SYDSydneyJevan Phillipou

    Taken with pick 35 in 2025 by Sydney, with 2025 pick 42.

    26.8PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Sydney · value will move

  • BRIBrisbane LionsKoby Evans

    Taken with pick 38 in 2025 by Brisbane Lions, with 2025 pick 38 (North Melbourne).

    24.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Brisbane Lions · value will move

  • BRIBrisbane Lions2026 round 3 (Hawthorn)

    From Hawthorn. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 58.

    21.8PAV at its slot

  • NMNorth MelbourneHugo Mikunda

    Taken with pick 48 in 2025 by North Melbourne, with 2025 pick 54.

    20.3PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at North Melbourne · value will move

  • WCWest CoastMatthew Owies

    From Carlton in the 2024 trade.

    20.2PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at West Coast · value will move

Lineage

Every asset from the trade, followed to the player it became. Open any ⇄trade button to see that trade here.

  • held by the club
  • after it left the club
  • bar length is PAV

HAWHawthorn received

  • 2025 round 1 (Carlton)

    Dyson Sharp (pick 13, 2025) at Essendon · 99.3
  • 2025 round 2 (Carlton)

    BID MATCHShare of Harry Kyle: 45.26

CARCarlton received

  • 2024 pick 14 (Hawthorn)

    Murphy Reid (pick 17, 2024) at Fremantle · 130.3

Trades in this lineage

PAV (Player Approximate Value): what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him to 2026, plus what an open stint is expected to add. A pick used to match a bid is worth its share of the player.

Players still at their club: values will move. Club colours only, no club marks.

  • How trades are valued
  • Outcomes methodology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Data deletion

© 2026 Statly