Skip to content
Statly
HomeTradesDraft record

Values to the end of the 2026 season. Values for players still at their club, and for picks marked *, will move. How this works

AFL trades / 2023 / Melbourne ⇄ St Kilda
AFL trades · 2023Melbourne ⇄ St Kilda

Melbourne are ahead so far

  • Melbourne

    +2.7

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2024 round 3 (St Kilda) → Sam Marshall
  • St Kilda

    −2.7

    PAV so far

    got

    • 2023 pick 42 → Ethan Read
  1. The tradeSt Kilda +3.82023
  2. DraftMelbourne +12.02023draft
  3. SeasonMelbourne +15.12024
  4. DraftMelbourne +6.82024draft
  5. SeasonMelbourne +6.52025
  6. SeasonMelbourne +2.72026
  • MELMelbourne gave2023 pick 42
  • STKSt Kilda gave2024 round 3 (St Kilda)

Values are PAV (Player Approximate Value) value lines at the end of 2026: what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him, plus what a stint still open is expected to add. A pick whose draft is to come is valued at its slot.

This trade now (2026)

  • MELMelbourne+2.7
  • STKSt Kilda−2.7

4trades in the chain

5clubs involved

Biggest values

  • BMBrody Mihocek33.2 · Melbourne
  • AHAngus Hastie29.1 · St Kilda
  • HSHarry Sharp28.8 · Melbourne

Swipe sideways to follow the timeline.

HASTIE29.1 · St KildaSHARP28.8 · MelbourneMIHOCEK33.2 · Melbourne2026MEL +2.7STK −2.72023This tradeMelbourne get 2024round 3 (St Kilda). StKilda get 2023 pick 42.2023GC ⇄ STKGold Coast get 2023pick 40 (BrisbaneLions) and 1 more. StKilda get 2023 pick 27…2023DraftHastie (pick 33).2024BRI ⇄ MELBrisbane Lions get 2025round 3 (Essendon) and1 more. Melbourne getHarry Sharp and 1 more.2025MEL ⇄ COLMelbourne get BrodyMihocek and 1 more.Collingwood get 2026round 3 (Melbourne) and…2025DraftMurray (pick 40),McCarthy (pick 55).

Timeline, oldest first.

  1. 2023. This trade. Melbourne get 2024 round 3 (St Kilda). St Kilda get 2023 pick 42.
  2. 2023. GC ⇄ STK. Gold Coast get 2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) and 1 more. St Kilda get 2023 pick 27 (Gold Coast).
  3. 2023. Draft. Hastie (pick 33).
  4. 2024. BRI ⇄ MEL. Brisbane Lions get 2025 round 3 (Essendon) and 1 more. Melbourne get Harry Sharp and 1 more.
  5. 2025. MEL ⇄ COL. Melbourne get Brody Mihocek and 1 more. Collingwood get 2026 round 3 (Melbourne) and 1 more.
  6. 2025. Draft. Murray (pick 40), McCarthy (pick 55).
  7. 2026: Melbourne +2.7, St Kilda −2.7.

This trade over time

Each club’s net on this trade at the trade, at each draft and at the end of each season. Above the middle line, the club is ahead.

End of 2026

  • MEL+2.7Melbourne
  • STK−2.7St Kilda
+16+80−8−16TradeDraft2024Draft20252026MEL +2.7STK −2.7
Show the values
Each club’s net on this trade at each point in time
WhenMELMelbourneSTKSt Kilda
At the trade, 2023−3.8+3.8
2023 draft+12.0−12.0
End of 2024+15.1−15.1
2024 draft+6.8−6.8
End of 2025+6.5−6.5
End of 2026+2.7−2.7

Trade details

What each club gave, what every asset became, and its value at the trade.

MELMelbourne gave St Kilda

  • 2023 pick 42used to match a bid · share of Ethan Read · at the trade 29.211.43

St Kilda received11.4

STKSt Kilda gave Melbourne

  • 2024 round 3 (St Kilda)used to match a bid · share of Sam Marshall · at the trade 25.414.09

Melbourne received14.1

On this trade alone

  • MELMelbourne+2.7at the trade −3.8
  • STKSt Kilda−2.7at the trade +3.8

With what each club did next

  • MELMelbourne+2.0−0.7 from 2 later tradesAll Melbourne chains
  • STKSt Kilda−16.6−13.9 from 1 later tradeAll St Kilda chains

Picks used to match a bid

A pick spent on a bid is swapped for a share of the player, by the points it covered.

BID MATCH

2023 pick 42 became a share of Ethan Read

Gold Coast matched a bid for Ethan Read at pick 9 in 2023. The price was 1,175.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

11.432023 pick 42’s share: 14.3% of Ethan Read’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Ethan Read
PickPoints coveredShare
R2 (MEL) - Pick 3654246.1%
R2 (BRL) - Pick 4046539.6%
R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 (this pick) · part used168.214.3%

R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 had 260.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (260.8 points) and Leftover-points pick (260.8 points).

BID MATCH

2024 round 3 (St Kilda) became a share of Sam Marshall

Brisbane Lions matched a bid for Sam Marshall at pick 25 in 2024. The price was 604.8 points, paid with 2 picks.

14.092024 round 3 (St Kilda)’s share: 37.5% of Sam Marshall’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Sam Marshall
PickPoints coveredShare
R3 (GCS) - Pick 4837862.5%
R3 (STK) - Pick 49 (this pick) · part used226.837.5%

R3 (STK) - Pick 49 had 135.2 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (135.2 points).

BID MATCH

2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions) became a share of Ethan Read

Gold Coast matched a bid for Ethan Read at pick 9 in 2023. The price was 1,175.2 points, paid with 3 picks.

31.602023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions)’s share: 39.6% of Ethan Read’s value

Points each pick covered of the price, and its share of Ethan Read
PickPoints coveredShare
R2 (MEL) - Pick 3654246.1%
R2 (BRL) - Pick 40 (this pick)46539.6%
R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 · part used168.214.3%

R2 (MEL) - Pick 42 had 260.8 points left over. They became Leftover-points pick (260.8 points) and Leftover-points pick (260.8 points).

Who they ended up with

Each player, after every later trade. A green dot means the player is still at the club.

MELWhat Melbourne ended up with

  • MELMelbourneBrody Mihocek

    From Collingwood in the 2025 trade.

    33.2PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Melbourne · value will move

  • MELMelbourneHarry Sharp

    From Brisbane Lions in the 2024 trade.

    28.8PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Melbourne · value will move

  • MELMelbourne2025 pick 71 (Western Bulldogs)

    From Collingwood. Not used at the draft.

    0.0PAV produced

STKWhat St Kilda ended up with

  • STKSt KildaAngus Hastie

    Taken with pick 33 in 2023, with 2023 pick 27 (Gold Coast) from Gold Coast.

    29.1PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at St Kilda · value will move

Now at other clubs

  • GCGold Coast2023 pick 40 (Brisbane Lions)

    From St Kilda. Gold Coast used it to match a bid for Ethan Read.

    31.60PAV, share of Ethan Read

    Ethan Read still at Gold Coast · value will move

  • FREFremantleTobyn Murray

    Taken with pick 40 in 2025 by Fremantle, with 2025 pick 46 (Essendon).

    24.9PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Fremantle · value will move

  • BRIBrisbane Lions2026 round 3 (Melbourne)

    From Collingwood. The 2026 draft is to come: valued at pick 53.

    23.7PAV at its slot

  • COLCollingwoodZac McCarthy

    Taken with pick 55 in 2025 by Collingwood, with 2025 pick 61 (Brisbane Lions).

    18.0PAV, produced plus expected

    Still at Collingwood · value will move

  • BRIBrisbane Lions2024 pick 49 (St Kilda)

    From Melbourne. Brisbane Lions used it to match a bid for Sam Marshall.

    14.09PAV, share of Sam Marshall

    Sam Marshall still at Brisbane Lions · value will move

  • GCGold Coast2023 pick 42

    From St Kilda. Gold Coast used it to match a bid for Ethan Read.

    11.43PAV, share of Ethan Read

    Ethan Read still at Gold Coast · value will move

Lineage

Every asset from the trade, followed to the player it became. Open any ⇄trade button to see that trade here.

  • held by the club
  • after it left the club
  • bar length is PAV

MELMelbourne received

  • 2024 round 3 (St Kilda)

    BID MATCHShare of Sam Marshall: 14.09

STKSt Kilda received

  • 2023 pick 42

    BID MATCHShare of Ethan Read: 11.43

Trades in this lineage

PAV (Player Approximate Value): what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him to 2026, plus what an open stint is expected to add. A pick used to match a bid is worth its share of the player.

Players still at their club: values will move. Club colours only, no club marks.

  • How trades are valued
  • Outcomes methodology
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Data deletion

© 2026 Statly