Values to the end of the 2026 season. Values for players still at their club, and for picks marked *, will move. How this works
Geelong are ahead so far
Western Bulldogs
−88.7PAV so far
got
- 2024 pick 17 (Geelong) → Cooper Hynes
- Matthew Kennedy
Carlton
−26.8PAV so far
got
- 2024 pick 38 (Geelong) → Harry OFarrell
Geelong
+90.5PAV so far
got
- Bailey Smith
- 2024 pick 45 (West Coast) → Jay Polkinghorne
St Kilda
+25.0PAV so far
got
- Jack Macrae
- The tradeGeelong +31.42024
- DraftGeelong +40.82024draft
- SeasonGeelong +58.62025
- SeasonGeelong +90.52026
- Western Bulldogs gaveBailey Smith, Jack Macrae
- Carlton gaveMatthew Kennedy
- Geelong gave2024 pick 17 (Geelong), 2024 pick 38 (Geelong)
- St Kilda gave2024 pick 45 (West Coast)
Values are PAV (Player Approximate Value) value lines at the end of 2026: what each player has given the club that drafted or traded for him, plus what a stint still open is expected to add. A pick whose draft is to come is valued at its slot.
This trade now (2026)
- Western Bulldogs−88.7
- Carlton−26.8
- Geelong+90.5
- St Kilda+25.0
1trades in the chain
4clubs involved
Biggest values
- Bailey Smith157.7 · Geelong
- Cooper Hynes66.2 · Western Bulldogs
- Matthew Kennedy54.3 · Western Bulldogs
Swipe sideways to follow the timeline.
Timeline, oldest first.
- 2024. This trade. Western Bulldogs get 2024 pick 17 (Geelong) and 1 more. Carlton get 2024 pick 38 (Geelong). Geelong get Bailey Smith and 1 more. St Kilda get Jack Macrae.
- 2024. Draft. Hynes (pick 20), OFarrell (pick 40), Polkinghorne (pick 44).
- 2026: Western Bulldogs −88.7, Carlton −26.8, Geelong +90.5, St Kilda +25.0.
This trade over time
Each club’s net on this trade at the trade, at each draft and at the end of each season. Above the middle line, the club is ahead.
End of 2026
- −88.7Western Bulldogs
- −26.8Carlton
- +90.5Geelong
- +25.0St Kilda
Show the values
| When | Western Bulldogs | Carlton | Geelong | St Kilda |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| At the trade, 2024 | −62.7 | +6.4 | +31.4 | +24.9 |
| 2024 draft | −70.1 | +5.0 | +40.8 | +24.3 |
| End of 2025 | −82.1 | −8.9 | +58.6 | +32.5 |
| End of 2026 | −88.7 | −26.8 | +90.5 | +25.0 |
Trade details
What each club gave, what every asset became, and its value at the trade.
Western Bulldogs gave
- Bailey Smith to Geelongfirst stint at Geelong · at the trade 97.9157.7
- Jack Macrae to St Kildafirst stint at St Kilda · at the trade 52.351.4
Total given209.2
Carlton gave
- Matthew Kennedy to Western Bulldogsfirst stint at Western Bulldogs · at the trade 25.554.3
Total given54.3
Geelong gave
- 2024 pick 17 (Geelong) to Western Bulldogsbecame Cooper Hynes · at the trade 61.966.2
- 2024 pick 38 (Geelong) to Carltonbecame Harry OFarrell · at the trade 32.027.5
Total given93.7
St Kilda gave
- 2024 pick 45 (West Coast) to Geelongbecame Jay Polkinghorne · at the trade 27.426.4
Total given26.4
On this trade alone
- Western Bulldogs−88.7at the trade −62.7
- Carlton−26.8at the trade +6.4
- Geelong+90.5at the trade +31.4
- St Kilda+25.0at the trade +24.9
With what each club did next
- Western Bulldogs−88.7no later tradeAll Western Bulldogs chains
- Carlton−26.8no later tradeAll Carlton chains
- Geelong+90.5no later tradeAll Geelong chains
- St Kilda+25.0no later tradeAll St Kilda chains
Who they ended up with
Each player, after every later trade. A green dot means the player is still at the club.
What Western Bulldogs ended up with
Western BulldogsCooper Hynes
Taken with pick 20 in 2024, with 2024 pick 17 (Geelong) from Geelong.
66.2PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Western Bulldogs · value will move
Western BulldogsMatthew Kennedy
From Carlton in the 2024 trade.
54.3PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Western Bulldogs · value will move
What Carlton ended up with
CarltonHarry OFarrell
Taken with pick 40 in 2024, with 2024 pick 38 (Geelong) from Geelong.
27.5PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Carlton · value will move
What Geelong ended up with
GeelongBailey Smith
From Western Bulldogs in the 2024 trade.
157.7PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Geelong · value will move
GeelongJay Polkinghorne
Taken with pick 44 in 2024, with 2024 pick 45 (West Coast) from St Kilda.
26.4PAV, produced plus expected
Still at Geelong · value will move
What St Kilda ended up with
St KildaJack Macrae
From Western Bulldogs in the 2024 trade.
51.4PAV, produced plus expected
Still at St Kilda · value will move
Lineage
Every asset from the trade, followed to the player it became. Open any trade button to see that trade here.
- held by the club
- after it left the club
- bar length is PAV
Western Bulldogs received
2024 pick 17 (Geelong)
Cooper Hynes (pick 20, 2024) · 66.2Matthew Kennedy
Matthew Kennedy · 54.3
Carlton received
2024 pick 38 (Geelong)
Harry OFarrell (pick 40, 2024) · 27.5
Geelong received
Bailey Smith
Bailey Smith · 157.72024 pick 45 (West Coast)
via 2023via 2024via 2024Jay Polkinghorne (pick 44, 2024) · 26.4
St Kilda received
Jack Macrae
Jack Macrae · 51.4